Author Archives: Chasing Aphrodite

Chasing Aphrodite’s European debut

On the eve of Aphrodite’s official return home, co-authors Jason Felch and Ralph Frammolino gave a presentation at a Sicilian university tracing the odyssey of the ancient statue from illicit excavation to controversial debut at the J. Paul Getty Museum and its symbolic role in the recent scandal that rattled the American art establishment.

“Felcholino,” as we were once dubbed by an arts blogger, were guests of Kore University in Enna, about 30 kilometers from when the Getty’s Aphrodite was dug up nearly 30 years ago. More than 150 students, faculty and local public officials attended the May 16 event, which served as the official debut for the book in Europe.

We recounted oil tycoon J. Paul Getty’s “addiction” to ancient art and how his eponymous museum inherited both his money and compulsion. Its $18 million purchased of the cult statue signaled the museum’s foray into an art market awash in looted artifacts.

The Getty’s voracious purchase of dodgy material led to the 2005 criminal indictment of its antiquities curator by a Roman court, triggering a scandal that revealed to what extent American museums had lied about patronizing the black market.

The presentation was made a day before the Fifth Century BC statue was officially inaugurated in its own room of the nearby Aidone museum. The event was covered by local and national Italian media, including one of Italy’s largest television networks.

The most popular question: Did they ever feel their lives were in danger from the Mafia?

“Even those we talked to, those considered ‘dangerous people,’ were gracious in the finest Italian tradition,” said Ralph.

Jason added: “We never had any direct threats but then again sometimes your life can be threatened and you won’t know about it.”

Afterward, we were treated to a sneak peekof the statue in its new home and a tour of the Morgantina dig site, form where many now believe the goddess was looted.

The Goddess Goes Home

Co-authors Ralph Frammolino and Jason Felch are in central Sicily this week to help locals celebrate the return of the Getty’s statute of Aphrodite. On May 16th we’ll be giving a presentation on Chasing Aphrodite at Kore University, which is sponsoring an academic conference on the goddess. The following day, we’ll be at the Aidone Archaeological Museum for the inaugurationof the exhibition celebrating the return of the goddess.

The view of Mt Etna from the ruins of Morgantina, in the center of Sicily. As in ancient times, the region is considered the bread basket of Europe, known for its fertile volcanic soil.

The Getty’s looted goddess will now live in a 17th century Capuchin monastery that is home to other objects found in the nearby ruins of Morgantina, an ancient Greek settlement.

The museum is now home to several other masterpieces of ancient art that once resided in American museums: the “Morgantina Silvers” from the Metropolitan Museum of Art and two marble busts representing Demeter and Persephone, which were owned by New York diamond magnate and collector Maurice Tempelsman. Local officials hope these masterpieces will help transform a sleepy village in the heart of Italy’s southern island into a center for archaeological tourism. We anticipate crowds of locals, a brass band or two, tears, wine and laughter as Sicily celebrates the return of its long lost goddess.

We’ll be posting news and pictures from the road. Meanwhile, you can find pictures from our 2007 reporting trip to the region here.

Jim Cuno’s awkward embrace of the Getty

In Wednesday’s LA Times, Jason Felch writes about the awkward marriage of a reformed Getty and its new CEO, a hawk on antiquities collecting.

“In naming James Cuno president and chief executive of the J. Paul Getty Trust, its board members surprised many in the art world by choosing a staunch defender of the unfettered acquisition of ancient art to lead an institution that, after a decade of scandals, has all but abandoned the practice.

Since 2001, when the Getty’s former antiquities curator Marion True was charged in Italy with trafficking in looted art, the Getty has returned dozens of ancient masterpieces it concluded were found through illegal excavations. More recently, the Getty has emerged as a leader in efforts to curb the looting that has fueled the market in ancient art.

Over that same decade, Cuno, 60, forged a reputation as an outspoken critic of efforts to curb the antiquities trade. In two books and many public appearances, he has called the efforts of foreign governments to regulate the trade in ancient art “nationalistic,” and has lamented the limits put on museums’ ability to collect art that has a murky ownership history.”

The upshot: “Cuno’s awkward embrace of a point of view he has long criticized creates a potential stumbling block for the Getty, which today relies heavily on cooperative relationships with Italy and other nations Cuno has openly criticized.”

Read the full story here.

James Cuno, critic of antiquities reforms, named head of Getty Trust

The Getty’s board has named Jim Cuno the new CEO of the J. Paul Getty Trust. Cuno has been an outspoken critic of claims by foreign governments for the repatriation of looted antiquities. He has also opposed efforts to reform the collecting practices of American museums. Starting in August he will preside over the Getty’s $5.3 billion endowment and a museum that has emerged as a leading voice of reform in the art world. Will Cuno change the Getty, or will the Getty change him?

Read the LA Times story here.

Forgery, Bribes and Tax Fraud: Excerpt in Los Angeles Times Magazine

Years before Marion True became antiquities curator at the Getty, her predecessor Jiri Frel orchestrated one of the most elaborate tax frauds in American museum history. At its center was the donation of recently looted antiquities at inflated values. To this day, those object form the core of the museum’s “study collection.” The story of the rogue Czech curator and the cover-up of his criminal activities are captured in an excerpt from Chasing Aphrodite in this month’s Los Angeles Times Magazine.

You can find the excerpt here.

Chasing Aphrodite debuts at the LA Festival of Books

Join us this weekend, April 30 and May 1, at the at the Los Angeles Times Festival of Books for the debut of Chasing Aphrodite. At 1 p.m. on Sunday we’ll be speaking on a panel moderated by LA Times editor Russ Stanton, “From the Front Page to the Book Shelf.” (The location will be SAL 101, event code 2043.) We’ll have advance copies of the book for sale and will stick around after the panel to sign copies and chat. On both Sat and Sunday you can find advance copies for sale at Skylight Books (Booth #84), near the USC Stage on Trousdale Parkway.

More info on the largest book festival in the country can be found here. See you there!

Five Star Review: “a wonderful read about greed”

Here’s our first customer review on Amazon.com, written by Jill Meyer, a top 500 reviewer for the site:

“Jason Felch and Ralph Frammolino, have produced an extraordinary look at the Getty Museum and its problems with stolen antiquities from Italy and Greece in their book, “Chasing Aphrodite”. They go behind-the-scenes of the art/museum world; a world filled with shady deals, outright forgeries, money laundering, and backstabbing that will challenge the previously held view of the genteel world of art collecting.

[…]

The book that has resulted from Felch and Frammolino’s painstaking work is a wonderful read about greed – in all forms – that has only recently been controlled by a new Getty Board and staff. Great book.”

Read the full review (and pre-order a copy of the book) here.

The Getty fights to keep its bronze athlete

A week after sending its statue of Aphrodite back to Italy, the Getty is fighting to keep another ancient masterpiece: its priceless bronze statue of an athlete, whose 1964 discovery by Italian fisherman is featured in the opening chapter of Chasing Aphrodite.

Co-author Jason Felch has the story in today’s Los Angeles Times:

“An Italian government official came to Los Angeles last week to propose a settlement to thelong-running dispute with the J. Paul Getty Museum over one of its most important ancient masterpieces, a bronze statue of a victorious athlete known as the ‘Getty Bronze.’

Gian Mario Spacca, president of the Italian region of Marche where the statue was hauled ashore by fishermen in 1964, met with Getty officials Friday to discuss a deal in which the statue would be shared as part of a broader exchange of art.

The talks come as an Italian court is expected to issue a verdict on the Getty’s appeal of a February 2010 ruling that the statue was illegally removed from the country four decades ago and should be returned.”

You can find the full story here.

The backstory on the bronze is here.

This is what the statue looked like soon after it was hauled from the Adriatic sea by Italian fishermen.

LA Times: Aphrodite Goes Home

Co-author Jason Felch has a story in Wednesday’s LA Times on the statue of Aphrodite’s return to Sicily. It contains a few scoops from the book on what convinced the Getty board to return the prized statue. Hint: it involves damning photos and the Mafia.

“The J. Paul Getty Museum’s iconic statue of Aphrodite was quietly escorted back to Sicily by Italian police last week, ending a decades-long dispute over an object whose craftsmanship, importance and controversial origins have been likened to the Parthenon marbles in the British Museum.

The 7-foot tall, 1,300-pound statue of limestone and marble was painstakingly taken off display at the Getty Villa and disassembled in December. Last week, it was locked in shipping crates with an Italian diplomatic seal and loaded aboard an Alitalia flight to Rome, where it arrived on Thursday. From there it traveled with an armed police escort by ship and truck to the small hilltop town of Aidone, Sicily, where it arrived Saturday to waiting crowds.

It was just outside this town, in the ruins of the ancient Greek colony of Morgantina, that authorities say the cult goddess lay buried for centuries before it was illegally excavated and smuggled out of Italy.”

Find the full story here.

LA Festival of Books Panel: From Front Page to Book Shelf

Co-authors Jason Felch and Ralph Frammolino will be on a panel discussing Chasing Aphrodite at the Festival of Books on Sunday, May 1st at 1 p.m. The panel is titled “From Front Page to Book Shelf.”  We’ll have early-release copies of Chasing Aphrodite for sale, and the discussion will be followed by a book signing. See you there!

More info at: http://events.latimes.com/festivalofbooks/